« The Right Kind of RedneckThe Trouble with Bygones »

Our Muslim Roots

06/05/09 | by Carolyn Jackson [mail] | Categories: religion, Islam, Obama Administration, foreign policy

I haven’t yet heard President Obama’s address to the Muslim world from start to finish. Instead, I caught sound bites and longer passages on the radio of a car I was driving yesterday across mountainous terrain. What I pieced together from three different public radio stations was refreshingly candid and at the same time sensitive to all.

As with his earlier address on race in America while still a candidate for election, the president treads where no other U.S. politician has dared to go. Unlike other presidents, Obama can speak of Islam from the familiarity of having lived in the world’s largest Muslim nation (Indonesia) and his paternal connections to the religion in Kenya.

Follow up:

These attributes were used by Obama’s critics during the election to demonstrate that he was “foreign” and un-American. I got a whiff of right-wing criticism Thursday when I lost one public radio station and struggled to find another. Someone, whom I couldn’t identify, was saying how foolish Obama was to go to Cairo University, a hotbed of jihadists, according to him. To visit the Muslim world was to lend sympathy to our enemies, or some such nonsense.

There are, of course, critics who believe the president didn’t go far enough in detailing his plan for reconciliation between Islam and the West, and others, although I didn’t hear them yesterday, who will say he gave away too much in acknowledging the agony of the Palestinians and denouncing settlements in the West Bank while, in his increasingly familiar balanced style, reminding the world of U.S. friendship with Israel and refuting the deniers of the Jewish Holocaust.

The America of which I want to be a part has found its voice in this president, not just in its measured rhetoric and reasonable tone, but in a broad accounting of history beginning with the European colonial period. Obama is at ease in the world, confident that history has given us this chance to intelligently address problems that have bedeviled us since the world wars of the twentieth century.

The president commended not only Gandhi but the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and the anti-apartheid movement of South Africa to Muslims as models for conflict resolution, but he neglected one role model I wish he had held up: Malcolm X.

Unlike King (and Obama), Malcolm Little was not born to middle class comfort but to violence and poverty. It was only in turning to Islam that he found his way in the world and into the American political scene. The narrative is complicated by the less than orthodox history of the Nation of Islam and Malcolm’s defiance of Elijah Muhammed, which led ultimately to his violent death, but it need not be neat and tidy to resonate with the poor and dispossessed to whom radical Islam is so appealing. I suspect that the president and his speech writers avoid Malcolm X because of his early denunciation of “white devils” and his refusal to renounce violence, but anyone who has read his autobiography (with Alex Haley) or seen Denzel Washington’s portrayal of him in Spike Lee’s marvelous film knows the story is both deeper and more complex than the narrative that has been crafted around King’s life and work. (We’ve rounded off the jagged edges, and we still gloss over King’s denunciation of war and poverty.) Today, almost every American, embraces the Christian Dr. King while the Muslim Malcolm X is rarely acknowledged for his contribution to racial progress. It should not be overlooked that Malcolm X extended the concept of dignity to many African Americans who rejected Christianity for its ties to slavery and segregation.

And Obama was speaking to Muslims. Malcolm X’s attraction to Islam was immediate and visceral, and he embraced it wholeheartedly, making a pilgrimage to Mecca where for the first time he got a vision of how people (well, men) of all races could unite in a sense of oneness.

What I admire about Malcolm X was his capacity to change over time and to grow increasingly mature in his insight and compassion. Like Obama, he found his way without a father who could guide him. Like King, he paid for his beliefs with his life. We shall never know what either King or Malcolm X might have become in their later years, but I’m not alone in believing that they would have come together.

Obama was, of course, speaking not only to Muslims but to the rest of us. And it might help if all of us could acknowledge an American hero who was Muslim.

6 comments

Comment from: Andrea Riquier [Visitor]
Terrific post as usual, Carolyn. My reading about Malcolm's life is limited, but I seem to remember that many people believe that it was when he came around to a more peaceful, open-minded interpretation of Islam than the Nation of Islam espoused that he began to be considered a threat and was assassinated.
06/05/09 @ 10:21
Comment from: Peggy Shriver [Visitor]
Thanks--insightful as always. Have you read "Martin and Malcolm" by Prof. James Cone of UTS? He would applaud much of what you have written. The "What ifs" of history haunt us in the early deaths of such people as these two. You may need Obama's skills in Utah!
06/06/09 @ 12:08
Comment from: Carolyn Jackson [Member] Email · http://www.progwoman.com
Actually, Peggy, my thoughts on this matter were heavily influenced by James Cone, but it was only after the post was published that I remembered. Anyone who hasn't read "Martin and Malcolm" would find it really illuminating, I think. Thanks.
06/07/09 @ 15:52
Comment from: Diana List Cullen [Visitor]
Terrific Carolyn. A revealing view for me. Thanks.
06/07/09 @ 17:40
Comment from: nancy henningsen [Visitor] · http://www.changinglives.info
Carolyn..only you would have the depth of knowledge to write this from your remote town in Utah. Noone else I know of has mentioned Malcolm X in connection with Obama's views but the analogy is apt. Keep sharing your insights.
06/22/09 @ 06:39
Comment from: Mary Foushee [Visitor]
What a treat to come back from a 96 degree stroll to Bluff's Post Office, and after reading an account of the current antiquity law violations in our neighboring town of Blanding, to read the gift of your thoughts was an unexpected joy. Thank you.
07/16/09 @ 16:15

This post has 12 feedbacks awaiting moderation...

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)

Random reflections on politics, the media, political activism, women's lives and spirituality, often inspired by travel, cultural events or what I read.

May 2012
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 << <   > >>
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    

Search

Categories

The requested Blog doesn't exist any more!

XML Feeds

powered by b2evolution free blog software